I finally decided to change my pressure back to a set EPAP 4 and IPAP 7 and reduced my AHI to 6.6. I still wasn't there though and I was having a large amount of mask leaks despite tightening the mask to the point where it was putting a lot of pressure and pain on my face at night. So I decided to lower the pressure to as low as it would go. I put my EPAP and 3 and IPAP at 6, loosened my mask and hoped for the best. My first night my AHI was 7.1, but the next night it was 2.9 and the next night it was 1.5 and the next it was 3.0. In the last 31 days I have had only one night (June 1st) where my AHI was above 5 and I have had 7 nights below 2. Overall for the last 31 days my AHI is 2.7. Not only that, but the amount of mask leaks I have had has been almost non existent (0.74% of time above Leak Rate threshold) and most of that has been when I've gotten up in the middle of the night to use the restroom.
I think I finally have it figured out and have been sleeping so much better and even longer than in the past. I still get tired during the day though and find myself dozing off in my recliner, but I truly do feel better when I wake up in the morning.